news usni.org

‘Launch the Flyswatter!’

Opinion

A 2016 U.S. Naval Institute proposal argues that submarines should carry a small “Flyswatter” missile to defend against aircraft in shallow water without sacrificing torpedoes or cruise missiles. This matters because aircraft can trap a submarine in littoral waters, where it cannot dive deeper, outrun the threat, or effectively fight back. The proposed SubSurface-to-Air Missile (SSAM) would launch from the submarine’s existing 3-inch countermeasures system. A floating canister based on the SSXBT probe would carry a modified Stinger or Starstreak missile to the surface, using bearing data from the periscope or sonar to target hovering helicopters and large maritime-patrol aircraft. The author rejects systems such as torpedo-tube-launched IDAS and VLS-launched AIM-9X because they consume space otherwise used for offensive weapons. The SSAM would be small, inexpensive, quick to fire, and usable while the submarine continues evasive maneuvers. Major technical challenges remain, including fitting the missile into the canister, launching it vertically from the surface, and guiding it after release. The proposal’s conclusion is that a modest, last-resort missile could either destroy an attacking aircraft or force it to break off long enough for the submarine to escape.
  • The proposal is designed around a strict tradeoff: a short-range, last-resort weapon launched from a countermeasures tube so submarines do not give up torpedo or missile capacity.
  • Its main uncertainty is not the missile technology itself but integrating a shortened missile, flotation and targeting links into a small SSXBT-derived canister that can launch vertically while the submarine evades.

Build this article’s timeline

Extract dated events, key actors, and open questions using the same timeline analysis available in Signal.

Log in to build

Timeline generation is available to signed-in community members.

Five Ws 🤖 4 AI prefills · 1 still unanswered
Who
Robert Smith, Karl Dönitz, C. Roger Wallin, and United States Navy
🤖 AI prefill
What
A 2016 U.S.
🤖 AI prefill
When When did this happen, or what is the timeframe?
Where
United States, Germany, and France
🤖 AI prefill
Why
Centers on SubSurface-to-Air Missile (SSAM), submarine vulnerability to airborne threats, and submarine stealth
🤖 AI prefill

Login to answer and earn XP for each gap you fill.

Submarine Air Vulnerability submarines, aircraft, shallow water, littorals, antisubmarine warfare SSAM Design Requirements SubSurface-to-Air Missile, SSAM, last-resort weapon, targeting, small size Countermeasure Launch System countermeasures system, canister, submerged launch, Mark 1, Flyswatter Existing Missile Proposals IDAS, AIM-9X Sidewinder, DCNS, Diehl, Raytheon Offensive Capability Tradeoffs torpedoes, Tomahawks, offensive firepower, opportunity cost, torpedo tubes
SubSurface-to-Air Missile (SSAM)100% submarine vulnerability to airborne threats96% submarine stealth94% shallow-water submarine operations92% antisubmarine-warfare (ASW) aircraft90% submarine countermeasures system89% Mark 1 SSAM “Flyswatter”88% minimal opportunity cost84% submarine-launched AIM-9X Sidewinder83% Interactive Defense and Attack System for Submarines (IDAS)82%
18
Manipulation Score: Low How much this article uses emotional framing vs. straight reporting
Loaded Language 1825%
Absolutist 1015%
Threat/Panic 2525%
Us vs Them 1215%
Engagement Bait 2020%
Manipulation score look right?

Factual Claims (5)

low military
A 2016 U.S. Naval Institute proposal argues that submarines should carry a small “Flyswatter” missile to defend against aircraft in shallow water without sacrificing torpedoes or cruise missiles.
By developing a missile to either destroy or deter enemy aircraft, U.S. submarines can be provided a means to “swat” away aerial threats.
medium military
Aircraft can trap a submarine in littoral waters, where it cannot dive deeper, outrun the threat, or effectively fight back.
If a submarine is detected by aircraft in the littorals, it cannot outrun the enemy, cannot hide by going deep, and cannot shoot back
low military
The proposed SubSurface-to-Air Missile (SSAM) would launch from the submarine’s existing 3-inch countermeasures system.
the submarine fleet should develop a weapon launched from the ship’s internal 3-inch countermeasures system
medium military
A floating canister based on the SSXBT probe would carry a modified Stinger or Starstreak missile to the surface, using bearing data from the periscope or sonar to target hovering helicopters and larg
Replacing the sensor apparatus with a missile would yield a convenient means of protecting the missile from sea pressure while getting it to the surface.
low technology
Major technical challenges remain, including fitting the missile into the canister, launching it vertically from the surface, and guiding it after release.
There are challenging obstacles to overcome, such as how to condense the missile’s length, perfecting the launch from a floating canister, and the initial targeting after launch.

Comments

Login to view and post comments.

🏠Portal 📰Links ❓Q&A 📅Events 💼Jobs